Two refined waterfront homes, one Mediterranean-inspired and one contemporary, with manicured lawns and private docks across a calm South Florida canal.

Admirals Cove's Spyglass Lane Sales Put a Price on the House Alone

November 19, 2026

On June 17, 2026, the house at 158 Spyglass Lane in Admirals Cove closed for $7.9 million. Nine days later, the house next door at 160 Spyglass Lane closed for $17 million. The two homes share a property line, a street and the same club. The house that sold for less than half as much was also the bigger one.

On Admirals Cove waterfront, the lot sets a floor that barely moves between neighbors. The house decides everything above it, and the per-square-foot figure buyers lean on can point the wrong way.

The County Puts the Same Number on Both Lots

The Palm Beach County Property Appraiser lists 158 Spyglass Lane as Lot 255 of Admirals Cove Parcel C, on 0.51 acre. Its neighbor, 160 Spyglass Lane, is Lot 256, on 0.49 acre, and the land is classified as Intracoastal canal frontage. For the 2026 tax year, the appraiser gives each lot the same land value, $5,150,000.

That figure is the appraiser's estimate, not a sale price. Still, it is the county's reading of what the dirt and the water are worth on their own, and it does not separate these two lots by a dollar. Both properties have a dock, and both added a boat lift in the last few years: 2024 at 158, 2023 at 160. In a July 1, 2025 report, The Real Deal described 158 as a half-acre waterfront home with 100 feet of waterfront and a dock.

So the $9.1 million gap between the two June 2026 sales comes from the houses.

Take Out the Land and the Houses Are Far Apart

The two houses differ in age and size. County records show 158 Spyglass Lane was built in 1990 and has 8,159 square feet under air. 160 Spyglass Lane was built in 2018 and has 6,804 square feet under air, with an elevator, pool and outdoor fireplace all dated to that year.

On the usual per-square-foot math, the June 2026 sales work out to about $968 a square foot for the 1990 house and about $2,500 for the 2018 house. That spread is wide. Subtract the county's $5.15 million land estimate from each sale and it gets much wider. What remains is roughly $2.75 million for the older house, or about $337 per square foot of living space, and roughly $11.85 million for the newer one, or about $1,742 per square foot. On this rough split, a buyer paid about five times as much per square foot for the newer house.

The appraiser's own split points the same way. For 2026 it values the improvements at 158 at $2,092,534, for a total market value of $7,242,534. At 160, the improvements are valued at $8,609,854, for a total of $13,759,854. The $7.9 million sale at 158 landed close to its land-plus-house estimate. At 160, the buyer paid well above it.

The older house also took a while to sell. The same Real Deal report said 158 went under contract in late June 2025 with an asking price of $10 million, after first being listed at $13.5 million that February. The recorded closing came a year later at $7.9 million. Over the same period, 160 changed hands twice: $15.75 million in 2025, then $17 million in June 2026.

Eagle Drive Shows the Same Pattern

A few streets over, two 2026 sales show the same split. Both houses had last sold for the same price.

The Real Deal reported that 370 Eagle Drive, the home built in 1998 for Céline Dion, sold for $12.5 million in an off-market deal. The house has 14,750 square feet on 0.66 acre, and the price came to $847 per square foot. It had been offered at $20 million in June and last sold for $7.6 million in 2021. The seller's agent told the same outlet there was "no chance" the house would be torn down, and called the community's amenities a "Disney for adults."

At 386 Eagle Drive, a 1992 waterfront home of about 6,000 square feet on half an acre went under contract in late June for $15 million, or $2,488 per square foot, The Real Deal reported. The owners had bought it for $7.6 million in 2024. It closed at $14.8 million in July.

Two houses on the same street started from the same $7.6 million purchase price. The one with less than half the living space sold for $2.3 million more. Neither sale tracked house size.

For scale, the Palm Beach County homes priced above $3 million that went under contract during the week of June 15 to 21, 2026 averaged $1,400 per square foot, according to the Douglas Elliman Eklund-Gomes report cited by The Real Deal. The following week, June 22 to 28, the average was $1,437. Admirals Cove sales from the same summer fell well below that average and well above it, inside a single gate.

Where the Lot Itself Moves the Price

The floor holds only when the lots are comparable. On a lot that is clearly larger, the land carries more of the price.

The biggest sale this fall was 176 Spyglass Lane. It sold for $34.5 million on 1.5 acres with more than 350 feet of water frontage, and its 19,200-square-foot house was remodeled in 2023. The Real Deal put the price at about $1,796 per square foot, a 43 percent increase over the $24 million the sellers paid in 2021. The buyer was the same owner who had just sold 370 Eagle Drive, moving within the community.

At 217 Commodore Drive, a lot changed hands before its house was finished. It is an unfinished custom home on 0.7 acre with 300 feet of waterfront, and it sold for $23 million in 2026. The seller had paid $14.9 million in 2023, and the house will be nearly 10,000 square feet when complete. According to The Real Deal, the deal totals $35 million once the construction contract is included.

The club's own descriptions explain why frontage matters this much. Admirals Cove says its custom waterfront lots have at least 100 feet of frontage and can accommodate boats of 70 to 120 feet. The Harbor Homes, with one residence per floor, mostly have docks for boats up to 34 feet. The community has five miles of waterways, more than 500 private docks, and a marina with 63 slips for yachts up to 130 feet, with the Jupiter Inlet about two miles north. Some boats fit only behind certain houses, and that limits which lots a given buyer will consider. For more on the boating side, see our guide to living on the water in Admirals Cove.

How to Read an Admirals Cove Comp

For two houses on similar lots, the useful question is what the house is worth on top of the lot. The county record answers part of it. Each parcel page on the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser site lists the land value, the improvement value, the year built, the area under air, and dated extras such as docks, lifts, pools and elevators. Comparing those lines with a recent sale shows how much a buyer paid for the house itself, as the Spyglass pair does.

For a seller with a 1990s house on a standard waterfront lot, 158 Spyglass Lane is the comparison to know. Its sale landed near the county's land-plus-house estimate after a long listing period. For a seller with a newer or recently rebuilt house, 160 Spyglass Lane and 386 Eagle Drive show buyers paying well above that estimate. Neither seller can price from a neighborhood average per square foot, because in 2026 the same street produced $968 and $2,500.

Club costs are a separate line in a buyer's budget. Our earlier post on how Admirals Cove membership and HOA costs work covers that part, and the Admirals Cove neighborhood page lists homes currently available.

If you own in Admirals Cove and want to know where your home sits relative to its lot, Jeanne Gordon can go through your parcel record alongside this year's Spyglass and Eagle sales and give you a figure based on your house, not the community average. Request Your Home Valuation and we will start with your lot.

Work With Jeanne

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.